Crankshaft failure can cause serious damage to an engine, requiring expensive repairs or even a full engine replacement. There are several reasons for crankshaft failure, such as design issues, lack of proper maintenance, and extreme working conditions. Understanding the common causes of crankshaft failure can help prevent issues and allow for early diagnosis.
.png)
Common Causes of Crankshaft Failure
- Fatigue Failure: Steel crankshafts can weaken over time. Small cracks can appear at stress points, like the edge of the oil hole in the crank pin. These cracks grow as stress repeats, and eventually, the crankshaft fails.
- Vibration and Dynamic Imbalance: Excessive vibrations can cause cracks in the crank pin and journal. Misalignment of the crank arm and radius can strain the Bearings, leading to fractures.
- Insufficient Lubrication: Without proper lubrication, friction and heat increase, causing faster wear on the crankshaft. If the main bearing journals or Connecting Rod journals lack enough oil, it can lead to overheating, which may eventually cause the crankshaft to fail.
- Overloading: Running an engine beyond the crankshaft’s load limit can cause it to bend, twist, or break. Ignoring the crankshaft’s tolerance can result in severe damage.
- Corrosion: Exposure to moisture or corrosive substances can weaken the crankshaft material, causing rust and cracks that reduce its strength and eventually cause failure.
- Improper Installation: Incorrect installation, such as poor alignment or improper torque, increases stress on the crankshaft. Misaligned bearings or wrong clearances between parts can lead to vibrations and premature failure.
- Bearing Failure: Worn or improperly fixed bearings can cause the crankshaft to lose support, resulting in uneven stress and fractures.
- Flywheel Issues: A loose flywheel bolt can affect the crankshaft’s balance and lead to fractures. Misalignment of the flywheel and crankshaft also stresses the crankshaft further.
- Mechanical Overload and Sudden Jamming: Unexpected issues like abnormal combustion or sudden jamming of engine parts can overload the crankshaft, causing it to fail under pressure.
- Forging or Casting Flaws: Manufacturing defects, such as imperfections in the crankshaft’s forging or casting process, can weaken it, making it more likely to fail under normal operational stress.
- Bearing Wear and Clearance Issues: Worn-out bearings or incorrect bearing clearances can cause uneven wear and excessive stress on the crankshaft. If not fixed, this can lead to failure.
How Fatigue Failure Affects Crankshaft Performance
Fatigue failure in crankshafts is a serious issue that can lead to severe engine damage. This type of failure often starts in areas with high stress or manufacturing flaws. These factors cause cracks to form and grow under repetitive loads.
Primary Causes of Fatigue Failure
Fatigue failure is mainly caused by:
High-stress concentration at weak points
Crankshaft fatigue causes manufacturing defects that create stress raisers
Cyclic loads, which repeatedly stress the crankshaft
Secondary Causes of Fatigue Failure
Additional contributing factors include:
Residual stresses from manufacturing processes
Corrosion and creep that weaken the material over time
Thermal cycling effects
Load Types Comparison
| Load Type | Impact on Crankshaft | Common Failure Location |
|---|---|---|
| Bending Loads | Maximum stress at center/ends | Journal fillets |
| Shear Loads | Cyclic twisting forces | Crankpin radii |
| Torsional Loads | Rotational stress | Oil hole edges |
Insufficient Lubrication
Proper lubrication is critical for crankshaft health. The crankshaft works at high speeds and faces significant stress from cylinder explosions. Without adequate lubrication, bearing surfaces wear out quickly, leading to bearing seizure and engine failure.
Lubrication Systems
For optimal performance, consider our guide to Lubrication System Maintenance. A well-designed oil delivery system ensures clean oil reaches critical components:
Straight-shot oiling systems prioritize main bearings
Cross-drilled passages improve rod bearing lubrication
Consequences of Poor Lubrication
Accelerated bearing wear
Thermal stress buildup
Increased risk of catastrophic failure
Regular inspection of oil viscosity and pressure is essential for prevention.
Case Studies
Recent research published in the Journal of Mechanical Engineering analyzed 200 crankshaft failures in heavy-duty diesel engines. Key findings include:
- 68% of failures originated from fatigue cracks
- Improper installation contributed to 22% of cases
- Only 10% resulted from material defects
Mechanical Overload Data
Studies show mechanical overload increases fracture risk by 30% (Smith et al., 2022). Critical thresholds:
- Torsional stress > 580 MPa
- Bending stress > 420 MPa
- Maximum safe RPM: 6,500 (varies by design)
Installation Best Practices
Proper Installation Checklist:
- Verify bearing clearance (0.025-0.075 mm)
- Use torque wrench for cap bolts (120-150 Nm)
- Align flywheel within 0.05 mm tolerance
- Prime lubrication system before startup
- Perform dynamic balancing test
Vibration and Dynamic Imbalance
Vibration and dynamic imbalance are major causes of crankshaft failure. These issues arise from various factors in the engine’s operation, putting excessive stress on the crankshaft and its bearings.
Torsional Vibration
Torsional vibration mainly occurs in diesel engines. It is caused by the pulsating torque from each cylinder’s firing. This torque makes the crankshaft twist slightly back and forth with each stroke, creating vibration. Over time, this repetitive stress can lead to cracks and eventual crankshaft failure.
Dynamic Imbalance
Dynamic imbalance comes from the movement of engine parts like Pistons and connecting rods. In inline engines, these components both move up and down and rotate. If they are not balanced properly, they create vertical forces and side-to-side vibrations, which can harm the crankshaft. Differences in weight between parts, such as pistons or connecting rods of different sizes, can make the vibrations worse.
Changes in engine components, such as unbalanced flywheels, clutch covers, or a warped crankshaft from overheating, can also lead to dynamic imbalance.
Effects on the Crankshaft
The combined effects of torsional vibration and dynamic imbalance put too much stress on the crankshaft’s bearings. This stress causes fatigue fractures, and sometimes, the crankshaft’s natural frequency amplifies these vibrations. This resonance leads to greater metal fatigue, causing the crankshaft to bend too much and eventually crack.
Prevention and Mitigation
To prevent crankshaft failure, it’s crucial to regularly check the balance of engine components. This includes ensuring that parts like flywheels or clutches are replaced with the proper balance. Performing Torsional Vibration Analysis (TVA) also helps detect dangerous frequencies and protects the engine from harmful vibrations.
.png)
Bearing Issues
Bearing problems are a common cause of crankshaft failure. The bearing’s job is to help the crankshaft rotate smoothly, but many factors can lead to bearing failure and cause serious engine damage.
Lack of Lubrication
Without enough lubrication, friction between the bearing and crankshaft increases. This can cause the bearing to seize or result in major engine damage. Proper lubrication is essential to reduce wear and extend the life of the crankshaft and bearings.
Improper Bearing Clearance
The clearance between the bearing and the crankshaft journal must be just right. If it’s too tight, metal can rub against metal, causing serious damage. If it’s too loose, the oil pump might struggle to maintain the right oil pressure. This can increase windage in the crankcase, reducing engine power and efficiency.
Misassembly
Improper assembly can also lead to bearing failure. Errors such as installing the shim incorrectly, reversing bearing caps, misaligning oil holes, or not seating the locating lugs properly can cause uneven stress and poor lubrication. These mistakes can quickly cause bearing wear and ultimately lead to crankshaft failure.
Dirt and Debris
Contaminants like dirt and dust in the oil can scratch the bearing surface. Over time, these scratches can form pits and grooves that trap debris and break the oil film. If not fixed, this can lead to severe crankshaft damage.
Excessive Bearing Crush
Excessive bearing crushes can put too much pressure on the bores, causing the bearings to bulge or bend. This often happens due to over-tightening during assembly or servicing. This pressure can damage the bearings and cause them to fail over time.
Visual Inspection and Symptoms
When checking the crankshaft, signs of bearing damage include deep scores on the journals, visible copper layers on the bearings, and scratches that catch a nail. These are all signs that the bearings are worn out and could lead to more severe crankshaft damage, like deep grooves. In these cases, resurfacing or even replacing the crankshaft may be necessary.
Bearing Wear Patterns
If wear is noticeable on the outside of the bearing surface but not in the center, it may indicate that the crankshaft journal is flexing. This could mean the bearing clearance needs to be slightly increased to extend the bearing’s lifespan.
Mechanical Overload and Abnormal Combustion
Mechanical overload and abnormal combustion are major causes of crankshaft failure. These issues put too much stress on the crankshaft, which can lead to bending, twisting, or even breaking, resulting in engine failure.
Mechanical Overload
- Overloading the Engine: Exceeding the crankshaft’s maximum load capacity is a key reason for failure. Continuous overload can bend or twist the crankshaft, eventually causing catastrophic failure.
- System Faults: Sudden engine jamming, often caused by gearbox issues, can create intense mechanical stress and overload the crankshaft. This type of stress is sudden and damaging to the crankshaft.
Abnormal Combustion
Pre-ignition: Pre-ignition happens when the fuel-air mixture ignites too early, creating high pressure during compression. This extra pressure can strain the crankshaft and cause failure over time.
Detonation: Detonation, or engine knock, generates high-pressure waves that vibrate the cylinder walls and crankshaft. These vibrations increase wear on engine parts, including the crankshaft, leading to its failure. The detonation also raises the temperature inside the combustion chamber, putting additional stress on the crankshaft.
Specific Effects of Abnormal Combustion
- Auto Ignition and Surface Ignition: Autoignition occurs when the unburned fuel mixture ignites too early. This leads to rapid combustion and high pressure, which affects the crankshaft. Similarly, surface ignition, caused by spark plugs or carbon buildup, can cause similar damage.
- Increased Heat Transfer: Detonation increases the combustion temperature. When the protective gas layer on the cylinder walls is removed, heat transfer worsens. The increased heat accelerates crankshaft stress.
- Engine Knock and Vibration: Engine knock creates pulsating pressure waves and vibrations in the cylinder. These vibrations strain the crankshaft and increase the likelihood of failure.
Case Studies
- V-16 Diesel Engine Failure: A V-16 diesel engine crankshaft failed after 20,000 hours of continuous operation at 1500 rpm. The failure was caused by abnormal combustion and mechanical stresses, including fatigue.
- Thermal Fatigue: A crankshaft fracture study revealed damage along the web between the journal and crank-pin. This was linked to thermal fatigue, poor lubrication, and excessive thermal loads.
Why crankshafts fail is key to keeping your engine running well and avoiding expensive repairs. Focus on good lubrication, careful installation, and regular checks to prevent common problems. It’s not just about fixing things when they break; it’s about taking care of your engine to ensure it lasts. A little attention now can save you from bigger problems later. Keep your engine running smoothly, and it will serve you well.