If your engine starts making strange noises or loses power, the Crankshaft might be failing. Signs like knocking sounds or low oil pressure often go unnoticed until serious damage occurs. Spotting the issue soon can prevent expensive repairs.
Signs of a Bad Crankshaft
If your crankshaft begins to fail, you’ll notice several key signs. Identifying these early can help prevent further damage and save you from expensive repairs.
crankshaft failure signs
- Knocking Noise: A failing crankshaft often makes a distinctive knocking or clunking sound from the engine. This noise is caused by mechanical failure.
- Low Engine Oil Pressure: A drop in oil pressure, shown by the oil pressure gauge or a warning light on your dashboard, means the crankshaft might not be working properly.
- Engine Stopping: In severe cases, a damaged crankshaft can stop the engine from running altogether. This is a clear sign the crankshaft has failed.
Common Structural Issues Leading to Crankshaft Failure
- Bearing Wear: Worn-out bearings can cause the crankshaft to fail. This often happens due to poor lubrication or incorrect bearing clearance.
- Loose Bearing Main Caps: Loose caps that hold the bearings can cause crankshaft failure.
- Distorted Bearing Bores: Overheating or mechanical stress can distort the bearing bores, which affects the crankshaft’s operation.
- Improper Bearing Clearance: Incorrect clearance between the bearings and the crankshaft can lead to excessive wear, which can cause failure.
Crankshaft Damage Indicators
- Forging or Casting Flaw: A crankshaft manufacturing defect can cause early failure.
- Bearing Failure: Complete bearing failure can seize the crankshaft or cause it to break.
If you notice any of these signs, pull over immediately and turn off the engine to prevent further damage. Depending on the extent of the damage, the crankshaft may need to be repaired or replaced. A remanufactured crankshaft can be a cost-effective alternative to a new one, or for older cars, a used crankshaft from a junkyard might be an option.
Always check the condition of the crankshaft Bearings, as damaged bearings can quickly ruin a new crankshaft.
.png)
Causes of Crankshaft Failure
Crankshaft failure can occur due to a variety of factors, each contributing to its degradation or breakage. Understanding these causes is essential for preventing damage and ensuring engine longevity. Below, we expand on the key reasons for crankshaft failure, backed with detailed examples, case studies, and data to support these findings.
1. Fatigue Failure
Fatigue failure is one of the most common causes of crankshaft damage, particularly in steel crankshafts. This type of failure happens due to repetitive stress cycles, even when the stress is lower than the material’s yield strength. Some of the contributing factors to fatigue failure include:
- Stress Points: Stress concentrations, particularly around features like oil holes on the crank pin, can initiate cracks. Over time, these cracks propagate due to cyclic loading.
- Corrosion and Residual Stresses: Corrosion from poor lubrication or exposure to extreme conditions can exacerbate fatigue. Similarly, residual stresses from manufacturing processes like machining or welding can weaken the crankshaft, making it more susceptible to failure under normal operating conditions.
Case Study: In a 2017 study by the Journal of Engineering for Gas Turbines and Power, researchers examined fatigue failure in crankshafts from diesel engines. The study showed that 70% of failures were attributed to cyclic stress and residual stresses, confirming that fatigue is a primary failure mode in crankshaft degradation.
2. Vibration
Torsional vibrations are another common culprit in crankshaft failure. These vibrations result from uneven forces acting on the crankshaft, which can cause cracks in the crank pin and journal areas. Over time, the vibrations lead to fatigue failure, particularly in high-performance engines or those subjected to heavy loads.
Example: A 2015 case from Automotive Engineering International reported a series of crankshaft failures in heavy-duty diesel engines where torsional vibration was found to be the primary cause. The vibration resulted from improperly tuned engine mounts and an out-of-balance flywheel, both of which contributed to premature failure.
- Solution: Vibration dampers and proper balancing during the engine’s assembly can mitigate the effects of torsional vibrations.
3. Insufficient Lubrication
Inadequate lubrication is a critical factor leading to crankshaft failure. When oil is insufficient or not circulating properly, it can cause bearing failure, which directly affects the crankshaft. High oil pressure, while often a sign of other issues, can also create misalignment and thermal stress, worsening the problem.
- Symptoms of Lubrication Failure:
- Increased engine temperature
- Sluggish or irregular bearing movement
- Unusual noises (knocking, grinding)
Data Support: A study by Engine Builder Magazine in 2018 found that nearly 60% of crankshaft failures in large industrial engines were related to bearing lubrication issues. Over time, the lack of oil results in metal-on-metal contact, which accelerates wear and tear.
4. Over-Pressurized Cylinder
Excessive pressure inside the cylinder, often caused by water leakage or a malfunctioning sealing system, can result in catastrophic crankshaft failure. The high pressure can cause the crankshaft to bend or even slip out of alignment.
Example: In a 2020 engine repair case at Auto Tech service center, water leakage within the Cylinder Liner caused a significant rise in pressure, leading to the bending of a steel crankshaft in a 6-cylinder diesel engine. The repair required not only a new crankshaft but also a full inspection of the Cylinder Head and sealing systems.
5. Cracks
Cracks often form in the high-stress areas of the crankshaft, such as the junction between the journal and web. These cracks can start small but grow over time, especially when the piston is at Top Dead Center (TDC). As the engine continues to operate, the cyclic loads can cause the cracks to propagate, leading to total failure.
Case Study: A well-documented case by Engineering.com showed a pattern of cracks forming in the TDC area of crankshafts in an industrial engine. The cracks grew slowly but were only detected during routine maintenance when the engine was disassembled.
- Critical Zones: Cracks often appear between 10 o’clock and 2 o’clock positions during TDC.
6. Bearing Issues
Crankshaft failure can be directly related to bearing issues, such as improper bearing installation or worn-out bearings. If bearing nuts are loose or the clearance between the shaft and axle is too large, the crankshaft will experience uneven loading, leading to premature fatigue.
Example: In a 2019 repair case reported by Diesel Power Magazine, the crankshaft failure in a commercial truck was traced back to a misaligned bearing assembly, which caused the crankshaft to wear unevenly and eventually crack.
7. Axial Clearance
Excessive axial clearance in the crankshaft assembly can lead to axial movement during engine operation. This movement increases stress concentrations, which in turn can cause fractures and premature failure.
Example: A 2021 analysis by Heavy Duty Trucking examined a fleet of trucks with excessive axial clearance. The findings revealed that 40% of engine failures in these trucks were linked to excessive axial movement.
- Solution: Regular maintenance checks to ensure proper axial clearance is within the manufacturer’s specifications.
8. Flywheel Issues
A loose or improperly secured flywheel bolt can lead to a dynamic imbalance in the crankshaft assembly. The resulting large inertia forces place excessive stress on the crankshaft, leading to fatigue and eventual failure, often at the tail end of the crankshaft.
Case Study: A field report from Advanced Auto Repair in 2020 showed multiple instances of crankshaft failure caused by flywheel bolt loosening. In each case, the engine experienced irregular vibrations that escalated until the crankshaft failed at the tail end.
9. Dynamic Imbalance
Dynamic imbalance can occur if the crankshaft is replaced with an unbalanced part or if the crank arm is misaligned during assembly. This imbalance generates strong vibrations that increase bearing load, ultimately leading to fatigue and fracture of the crankshaft.
- Signs of Imbalance:
- Uneven engine performance
- Excessive vibrations at specific RPM ranges
10. Improper Grinding or Straightening
Improper grinding or straightening, especially cold straightening, can introduce harmful residual stresses in the crankshaft material. These stresses weaken the crankshaft, making it vulnerable to failure under long-term alternating loads.
Expert Opinion: According to a 2019 article in Automotive Repair News, cold straightening processes should be avoided for high-performance engines, as they tend to introduce residual stresses that accelerate wear.
11. Overspeed or Emergency Braking
Exceeding the engine’s rated speed or applying emergency braking can cause a sudden overload on the crankshaft, increasing the likelihood of failure. These actions generate forces beyond the crankshaft’s design limits.
Example: In a high-speed testing scenario, a crankshaft was found to have fractured after an emergency braking event in a 2020 high-performance engine, exceeding the engine’s rated speed by 15%.
12. Casting or Forging Flaws
Although rare due to modern manufacturing standards, casting or forging flaws can still result in crankshaft failure. These flaws can include air pockets or uneven material properties, which weaken the crankshaft and make it more susceptible to failure.
Industry Data: A report from Manufacturing Engineering in 2018 found that less than 1% of crankshafts in modern engines failed due to manufacturing defects, thanks to advanced quality control systems in place.
Consequences of Crankshaft Failure
Crankshaft failure can cause serious and expensive damage to your engine and vehicle. Here’s a look at the main consequences:
- High repair and replacement costs: Fixing or replacing a crankshaft is expensive, often leading to significant financial loss. This is a major concern for vehicle owners.
- Potential loss of life: If the crankshaft fails while the vehicle is moving, it could cause a severe engine failure, which might lead to accidents or injury.
Engine and Component Damage
- A failed crankshaft can damage the connecting rods and pistons. If the pistons hit the cylinder tops, they can severely damage the intake and exhaust valves.
- The failure can also affect the bearing main caps, causing distorted bearing bores and improper bearing clearance, worsening the damage.
Common Symptoms of Crankshaft Failure
- Knocking noises from the engine are a common warning sign.
- Low oil pressure, shown by a gauge or warning light, is another key symptom.
- In extreme cases, the engine may stop running, requiring immediate attention.
Catastrophic Engine Failure
- Crankshaft bearing failure can result in total engine failure. If this happens, the vehicle may need to be towed for repairs and diagnostics.
Important Notes
- Crankshaft Position Sensor Failure: If the sensor fails, the engine will still run, but poorly. If you don’t fix it, you could cause damage to other parts, like the catalytic converter.
- Crankshaft Failure: A damaged crankshaft needs immediate attention. If you continue driving with this problem, you risk complete engine failure or a breakdown.
Being aware of the signs of crankshaft failure can save you from expensive repairs and help your engine run well. Regular maintenance, early detection, and proper care are important for extending your vehicle’s life. Catching a small problem early can stop a bigger one later. Take care of your engine, and it will thank you!